I love my hiring managers. As a recruiter, I’m supposed to say that, right? Well, if we’re being totally honest here, I do love
some of my hiring managers, but others … not so much. Being in the recruiting business requires you to work with hiring managers, whether you are a corporate recruiter, agency or independent. They are the ones who give us the job orders / descriptions to work with, and ultimately the money for our paychecks, but not all of them do it the same way. For example:
Hiring Managers We Love:· Provide detailed information about the job beyond just the required skills, responsibilities and education. This includes things like company history and culture, team dynamics, manager styles, career path, reason the role is open and how long it’s been open, what type of personality that works best there, etc.
· Give feedback on resumes within 24-48 hours.
· Make time to interview candidates.
· Make decisions quickly.
· Make fair offers.
· Have a tried and true on-boarding process.
· Get involved in the hiring process to help “sell” their position/company to “A” candidates.
Hiring Managers Who Need Improvement:
· Provide a job description that does not include everything listed in the top bullet above.
· Tell recruiters the job is urgent, then go MIA (missing in action).
· Take what seems like forever, or never, provide feedback on resumes or after interviews.
· Miss or repeatedly reschedule candidate interviews after they’re already set.
· Want to continue interviewing more people after they’ve interviewed a candidate they like.
· Make low-ball offers.
· Don’t have everything ready for the candidate’s first day (e.g. computer, assigned cubicle, mentor, etc.).
The “hurry up and wait” syndrome seems to be a reoccurring trend right now. Several job orders are deemed urgent where the manager expects you to jump through hoops, but then never gets back to you. That happening once in a while may be understandable, but on almost all job orders from that manager? Hmmm…. So what can be done?
I attended the annual TalentNet Live (TNL) conference this past week (which was great by the way:
http://wordpress.talentnetlive.com/), and one of topics covered was about partnering with your hiring managers. Below are just a few ideas of theirs and my own for preventing these problems from arising:
· Ask manager up front things like:
-
“What keeps you up at night?”-
“What projects are coming up that we can be proactive on with our searches?”-
“What can I do to improve the recruiting process for you?”
-
“Why do you work here?” (helps to sell the role to a candidate)
· Tell him you hope to build up trust so you can set up interviews for him even if he hasn’t seen the resume yet.
· Get times the manager is available to speak with you, as well as to interview. Be sure to find out what’s the best way to reach him and get a backup contact for when he’s not available.
· Set up a post-interview feedback meeting before the interview even takes place.
· Find out the process for gathering feedback from multiple interviewers. If it seems unstructured and/or that it could slow down the process, provide them with a simple feedback form that can be filled out quickly and returned to the hiring manager.
· Tell manager if he doesn’t provide feedback within 24-48 hours, you will assume the role is no longer urgent and will go ahead and close it. (Bold, I know, but I love this idea!)
Again, just a few ideas, but these could get you started if you’ve encountered hurdles. Remember to present yourself as the expert up front and spend some quality time with your managers. This will allow you to partner with them rather than just be an order taker. If they balk at meeting with you, remind them that it will save them time and money on the back end. Good luck!
“Make Your Hiring Managers Your Partners”
Michael Goldberg, Freeman’s Talent Acquisition Leader
Mark Sullivan, Time Warner Cable’s Director of Talent Acquisition (TX region)
Marianthe Verver, NeoSpire Managed Hosting Recruiter